Consultant: pollinator or parasite?
Some consultants are extractive.
Recently, I sat down to a delightful dinner with a CEO. Conversation meandered over a variety of topics, both philosophical and practical. At one point, they said something like
I have not often seen consultants add immense value. I’ve seen lots of times where consultants have been hired, they go through a process, they get paid, and then they’re on their way. And because they’re not invested in the mission, it’s just all too easy to provide some advice and move on.
Some consultants are extractive. They are like mosquitoes buzzing about, looking to suck life out of their victim.
Oof.
These are the Parasites. They find a host, latch on, and pull out whatever they can, for themselves.
I’ve hired and worked with consultants myself, but most of my experience with bad players comes secondhand, through the CEOs I advise.
We started a campaign years back that crashed and burned. The consultant that was leading it [had to step away]. I can certainly understand that, but we were about a year into the conversation, and when they left all of the institutional knowledge also went out the door, and so the whole thing [fell] apart. —CEO of a large global nonprofit
Another CEO who leads an organization that supports organizations across the sector told me how they produced a large set of helpful resources, providing them for free. A consultant took them and began selling them. You can’t make this stuff up.
As another CEO told me and a group of other CEOs: “A lot of professional services firms in the sector are predatory.”
In this week’s episode of The Nonprofit CEO Podcast, Rick Santos, President and CEO of Church World Service, described the same pattern:
Sometimes you can get consultants who are very mercenary. They come in, they do it for a fee, and then they leave and hear my recommendations and they’re gone.
These are harsh words. But if someone is really extractive and/or predatory, they are taking from the people the organizations exist to serve. When this happens, I fill up with righteous anger pretty quickly, too.
Harsh words are warranted.
Now, I have a stake in this conversation, too. I have spent 26 years in the nonprofit sector, including 14 years in a $130M organization. The legal name of my business includes the word “consulting,” and that’s what some people would call what I do. So I can also see that not all “consultants” are Parasites or mosquitoes.
I talked to the leadership team…and I also talked to some of their critics…I didn’t talk to a management consultant or a leadership consultant. And I think actually in hindsight, that is something that I should have done. —Johnstone Ndunde, CEO of SIL Global, in an upcoming episode
By not pulling in outside counsel, CEOs risk burning significant organizational resources in a bad decision: in staff morale, in culture, in their own standing internally. They also risk torching donor trust and damaging their reputation.
Penny wise, pound foolish.
But some consultants are Pollinators. Pollinators move good things around. They stop in a new place, bringing benefit to that place. Pollinators are always learning, and then they move along to bring benefit elsewhere. These people create value wherever they go.
Pollinators are essential to the system.
Pollinators take something too. They get paid. But the place is more fruitful after they’ve gone. Some of the greatest expertise lies in people who have done something similar with a variety of other organizations. Outside help can be a tremendous accelerator of good things: growth, savings, impact, measurement, learning, clarity, communication.
Rick brought in outside help early in his tenure at Church World Service. He described what he inherited:
The good news and the bad news about Church World Services is that it had been functioning really well for about 20 years, but it hadn’t really changed much in those 20 years.
So he went looking for consultants, and found good ones:
We found some really good consultants who helped us think through how do we do this in the best interest of the organization? How do we do it? With change, there’s always things have to break, right? You have to break things in order to change them sometimes. And so how do we do that with the least amount of disruption?
When the consultants helped him present their findings, his leaders accepted them: “I thought they were so graceful in the way they accepted and said, OK, got it.”
Consultants were essential to understanding what was going on, seeing that in a wider experience set than one organization, and helping him lead change through the executive team.
Rick knew what he was looking for. He chose: "people I had worked with earlier in my career or in my other role, people who I really thought knew this work, who knew the nonprofit world really well."
Most CEOs don’t have that history to draw on. They’re hiring someone they’ve never worked with.